Friday, December 28, 2007

Neville Cup Final: Pembroke 1 TRR 6

Three Rock won the Neville Cup for the first time since 2002, beating an almost unrecognisable Pembroke side comprehensively.

The tie was effectively sealed by half-time as Rovers converted three of their four penalty corners last Sunday against a team that retained only Patrick Good, Gordon Elliott and Alan Sothern from their semi-final side that overcame Glenanne.

Three Rock, for their part, were bolstered prior to tip-off by the clearance of both Mitch Darling and Andy McConnell to play, despite arriving back from international duty just two days previously.

In a fairly lifeless opening, Pembroke had a couple of half chances, Dougie Good first unlucky not to get a corner after Gordy Elliott’s run and then missing a sharp chance after Morris Elliott crossed.

And so it was that Rovers scored from their first shot. It came from a Peter McConnell penalty corner, awarded for Pembroke failing to retreat five yards at a long corner.

McConnell doubled the advantage from his side’s second corner, pushing low into the right hand corner.

And the first half scoring was complete from Rovers’ fourth corner, Kyle Good improvising well from a bad push-out to fire to the back post to the waiting Michael Maguire tapped home.

After a first half of few chances, the second opened up a lot more, with Rovers creating a host of chances. Tim Hill and Kyle Good both missed chances close in, before the Good – recently called into the Irish under 18 squad – got a deserved fourth.

Andy McConnell latched onto the ball at the top of the D to feed Tim Hill on the left. He dinked the ball over the onrushing Ken Mulcare and Good made no mistake from, slamming home from three yards.

Rovers had, at this point, managed to rotate the bench to give another Irish under 18 player, Stephen West his first team debut in goal.

Good set up Andy McConnell for the fifth moments later before Pembroke rallied with a scrambled effort to bring the score back to 5-1 with ten minutes remaining.

Gary Ringwood, though, rounded up the scoring with a delicate one-handed effort in the closing moments.

Afterwards, on receiving the gigantic Neville Cup, Rovers skipper Peter McConnell said “It’s always nice to win against Pembroke especially up here [in their ground].”

It will be argued, though, that the nature of the Pembroke opposition may dull the victory somewhat especially with a number of senior players not playing despite being in the country and fit to play.

As it was, with five players making their Pembroke firsts competitive debuts, Rovers found it a lot easier to inflict the Ballsbridge side’s first defeat since January.

Pembroke: Ken Mulcaire, Alan Sothern, Douglas Good, Rowan Pearson, Paudie Carley, Patrick Good, Duncan McKeen, Scott Lowry, Stuart Loughrey, Morris Elliott, Gordon Elliott
Subs: Michael Tijs, Simon Walsh, Stuart Garrett, Conor McDermott

TRR: Charlie Henderson, Michael Maguire, Gavin Bourke, Neil Lyons, Alan Bothwell, Mitch Darling, Colin Huet, Tim Hill, Gary Ringwood, Pierre Quesnel, Peter McConnell
Subs: Ross Varian, Stephen Macken, Kyle Good, Stephen West, Andy McConnell

20 comments:

Anonymous said...

Pembroke had regular players in the country and fit to play? Glad they got whooped

This post has been edited from the original

Anonymous said...

pembroke didn't have any regular players in dublin fit to play. they picked the best possible team given the circumstances.

Anonymous said...

I was at the game and didnt recognise any of the pembroke players but gordie elliott and alan sothern, i found the first 20mins to be an evenly fought contest but with their 5th(?) team goalie between the posts all rovers had to do was hit the target it seemed...what i did feel was that the TRR team made a lot of basic errors and were unlucky not to be punished on several occasions, the scoreline somewhat flattered them...nonetheless congrats to TRR

Anonymous said...

i heard from the grape find that pembroke were lucky to get that team out, nobody wanted to play. i would nearly understand that. if pretty much the whole 1st team dosnt give a shit about the cup why should the 2nds bail them out. bar the 3 exceptions.

Anonymous said...

three rock deserved it. pembroke obviously didn't care with half their team off snowboarding, pity cos there was a big crowd which shows people want to watch a bit of hockey on stephen's day. heard nidge was around but didn't play. any truth?

Anonymous said...

i was at the game and it was a massive dissapointment to see a 2/3rd team trying to take on a div 1 team.Its not as if pembroke players didnt know this game was on.any other team,Fingal,glenanne,monkstown i bet would have had a full strength squad...Do you not enter competitions to win them.. why bother enter if this is how you play a final..no disrepect to the players who turned out..I wonder will any be included in any pembrokes 1st team plans for the rest of the campaign.Pembroke as a club should question there commitment to this competition,there semi final was the final in ther eyes. yellow jersey fan

Anonymous said...

Heard it through the GRAPE FIND?extraordinary!Those pembroke players who went away are like the man united players at their Xmas bash! Shocking attitude. I thought it would be an even enough game, with Rovers missing a rake of players too, but obviously to lose 6-1 in any final is an absolute hosing!

Fitzgibbon

Anonymous said...

Pembroke have come in for alot of stick on this website and some of it unjustified but they really let themselves down on stephens day. Cant understand how they did not insist conor harte played. He was fit and in the country. Also gordie elliott deserves alot of applause for the way he played that day. He gave it 200% when under the circumstances he could of not bothered. Good club man!

Anonymous said...

Agree with all Pembroke committment comments. A disgrace for such a big club. Heard on the grape-vine that Nigel Henderson was at home on Stephens Day, and Conor Harte was at home in Cork. Surely the Pembroke coach should shoulder alot of blame for the team that was put out? This is not good for Pembroke. Fair play to the club men who did their best on the day. Congrats to TRR - silverware is silverware.

Anonymous said...

pembroke play in europe and in the club championship every year . they are unbeaten in the league and probably play the best hockey in ireland . To expect players like conor harte who is at home for christmas to return to dublin on stephens day for a fixture which is equivalent to the league cup is asking a bit much i feel . Added to this the fact that their seconds are a very accomplished outfit and that their south africans are in africa and one gets a more objective outlook on things . Pembroke im sure did their best . Hockey is not professional yet they consistently display an exemplary attitude .
The criticism is harsh .

Division 1 player who doesnt play for pembroke

Anonymous said...

teams who strive to go forward should take every game seriously. that comment about being 'not a professional sport' is an absolute cop out. everyone can sympathise with connor coming from cork but having 13? players missing. they should be banned from the cup that way the likes of monkstown, chc, airlingus could have played three rock. fair play to sothern, gordy and paddy for playing.

Anonymous said...

get over it,so players were away for this game,isnt christamas a family time after all?and would it not be better suited to hold an exhibition game on this day rather than a competitive final,years ago it used to be that a presidents 1XI played against the Irish squad or leinster senior squad,to me this makes far more sense and would be a great spectacle...

Anonymous said...

How many matches has Nidge played for Pembroke 1sts this year? prob not even a handful. Give the guy a break..he was away with the Irish team before Christmas and has given years of extraordinary commitment and dedication to both club and country. Can the man enjoy a couple of days off over christmas with his family? ..same goes for the other Irish players and those travelling home for Christmas.

Anonymous said...

I think one of the main points is that in the past few years, while first XI teams have moaned about this cup, the matches have always been competitive and the trophy well fought out with just a few players missing.

the nature of pembroke's (3xSA + from cork, irish squad) side means they will always lose players at chrimbo. why not use it a la arsenal in the carling cup as a development team so they get exp and will be able to play in the final?

this year was an exception to previous finals where only a few players were missing. rovers made an effort to get players released while pembroke werent able to get players back. pity, cos as was said, there was good crowd out.

on another point made here. in years gone by, the day was used for an Irish trial. wouldn't be very feasible these days as there seems to be annual 'warm weather' training trips.

Anonymous said...

Here's another way to look at the game on Stephen's day:

Pembroke had 2/3 very good chances in the 1st 20 minutes. Included in this was a short corner that wasn't given and a big miss at the back post with the goal wide open. It was still 0-0 at this stage. Then Rovers scored 3/4 of their short corners.

So Pembroke with a mixed bag of players who had never played together before in Div 1 weren't carved open by a pretty full strength Rovers side in the 1st half? Granted the 2nd half was a much different story. It seems to me that the game was a much more competitive fixture than the final scoreline suggests and that the youngsters at Pembroke did themselves proud, Loughery, Lowery, Walsh, Garrett, and McDermott. If Pembroke had been more clinical we could all be talking about something different for a change!

Perhaps it should be changed to be a "challenge" match, or the U21 cup final, there's normally good hockey played at that.

Really, really anonymously anonymous.

Anonymous said...

firstly the comment about nidge is well outta order. Than man played games for pwhc with broken toes so if anyone deserves time off it should be him

the real question is the lads who were away...if the coach isnt even there whos going to set an example?
this is truly a show of things to come at that club....i even hear byron dunne refused to play because of the way hes been treated...good on him...we cudnt care less about you all year now we want you to play.
dave

Anonymous said...

how exactly has byron dunne been treated then?you all seem to know so much about pembroke and their so called "let down" players...if so then explain because im sure everyone out there would like to know?

a lot of misinformed comments are being posted on this site and frankly its getting old...i mean i know nobody ever likes a successful team but there seems to be extra hatred surrounding this current pembroke team and i for one would like to know why?it couldnt be just jealousy and it seems that these comments are coming from within....i dont think any other hockey player in leinster thats part of a div 1 team would care so much about pembroke and whos in/not in their team every week...

id also be keen to hear what you think is "to come" at this club??because i mean you seem to know it all so surely you can see the future and let us all in on this vision you have of the future of pembroke wanderers hockey club.....

Anonymous said...

blah,blah,blah...trinity for they league 2009.

Anonymous said...

totally agree with the comment about trinity there gonna dominate in 2009. i know alot of people feel that this years first div is irrelavent because the mighty trin arn't in it.

Anonymous said...

kilkenny for the league 2012..